What is the vision behind Connect 3 Million?

Connecting the Channel Islands to mainland France

Introduction

‘Connect 3 million’ is the working title of the project to connect 3 million people in lower Normandy to Guernsey, via Jersey, with a maximum commute time of one hour.

A fixed link between Guernsey and Jersey is more than just an infrastructure project. It is a social, economic and environmental project with the potential to transform the lives and prospects of citizens, businesses and society in the Channel Islands.

Key messages:

1. Benefits

  • Establish a commuting population where there is income tax take, but no additional stress on island infrastructure.
  • Enrich trade, tourism, and social cohesion between the islands.
  • Double GDP, increase Government general revenue by £500m per annum in 10 years.
    • Early estimate is 8,000 passenger movements a day in each direction, between Jersey and Guernsey. (Source: Ramboll.)
    • DFM independently believe this is fair and for passenger movements to increase at 5%-7% a year.
    • Jersey Airport to St Helier passenger movements have been excluded from revenue estimates.
  • Economic benefit
    • Fiscal stimulus from inward investment, and tax revenues of 10% of construction cost.
    • Critical mass savings estimated at £200m a year. (Source: Chris Brock, Critical Economics.)
    • Alleviate housing
    • Diversify the economy
    • Inward investment

2. Proposition

  • Commuters will access shuttle trains from underground stations located in St Peter Port, Jersey Airport and St Helier.
  • The working train specification is a 120mph Bombardier Talent battery powered train, which bridges electrified and non-electrified track sections.
  • Target journey times
    • St Peter Port to Jersey Airport in 7 minutes
    • St Peter Port to St Helier in 15 minutes
  • Timings
    • Phase 1: connect Guernsey to Jersey first, due to jurisdictional similarities.
      • 1 year feasibility study, 2 years to dig, 1 year to fit out.
      • Consider freight and cars.
    • Phase 2: connect Jersey to France

Source: Rambol

3. Government role

  • Funds a feasibility study which includes passenger modelling.
  • Provides a guarantee for ‘passenger volumes’, not ‘costs’.
  • Invites private sector bids to build and subsequently finance.

4. Estimated costs

Build costs will depend on water voids, geology and technology used, as determined by the feasibility study.

  1. Tunnel Boring Machines (TBM) potentially £20m per km.
    TBMs create a sealed tube as they advance through water voids.
  2. Mining the tunnel (drilling and blasting) potentially £5m per km.

Modern drilling and blasting techniques address water voids by freezing the rock face.

Whilst drilling and blasting is the preferred solution, the geology and water management may require a TBM to be used.

Illustrative costs, including £100m each for three stations, 8,000 passenger movements a day growing at 5%:

4. Next steps

DFM will finance the travel and hotel expenses for a team of experts to talk to the Governments of both Guernsey and Jersey.

The team at DFM give their thanks to the support we have received from

Appendix

Rail Link

Talent 3 train

£150m – Saves on costs of electrifying track.

Illustrative underground station

£100m

Illustrative station entrance

Examples of other jurisdictions

Faroe Islands

10x uplift in passenger numbers compared to ferry services, with 7% growth thereafter.

The Eysturoyartunnil subsea tunnel network opened in 2020.

The tunnels were funded by a joint venture partnership between Government and private sector.

The Faroe Islands have 53,000 inhabitants and now 20 tunnels, of which three are long tunnels under the sea. Two more are already under construction, and another 14 are on the drawing board.

faroebusinessreport.com/geography/societal-game-changer-the-subsea-tunnels/

The Eysturoy Tunnel

The Eysturoy Tunnel connects both sides of the bay of Skálafjørður using two tunnels that connect to a roundabout under the seabed at mid-bay.

Started: 2017
Completion date: 2020
Length: 11.24 km
Lowest point: -187 metres
Funding: Toll fees
Cost: £140m

The Sandoy Tunnel

Started: 2018
Completion date: 2023
Length: 10.8 km
Lowest point: -147 metres
Funding: Toll fees
Cost: £120m

Suðuroyar Tunnel

Suðuroyar tunnilin, a submerged fixed-link in the Faroe Islands, will link the island of Suðuroy to Sandoy.

Started: 2020
Completion date: 2030
Length: 25 km
Funding: Toll fees
Cost: £400m

Norway

Ryfast Tunnel

Started: 2018
Completion date: 2023
Length: 10.8 km
Lowest point: -147 metres
Funding: Toll fees
Cost: £120m

Sweden and Denmark

Øresund Bridge

Political barriers prevented the vision becoming reality for decades. The award-winning double-track railway and motorway opened in 2000, allowing 3.7 million people to live and work on either side. www.oresundbron.com

16 km road and rail link between Sweden and Denmark.

A cable-stayed bridge runs nearly 8 km (5 miles) to an artificial island where it transitions into a tunnel that runs another 4 km (2.5 miles).

The financing was funded by the Norwegian government (with the addition of toll fees)

Switzerland

Gotthard Base Tunnel

Started: 1999
Completion date: 2016
Length: 57 km
Depth: 2,300 metres
Funding: Toll fees
Cost: £8.5bln

Relevant cost proxies indicate a range of outcomes

Source : Ramboll

Relevant study into mining costs from Greece:
Assuming two 8m diameter tunnels are dug, indicative costs of excavation from Andreas Benardos work:

Source: Assessing and benchmarking the construction cost of tunnels Andreas Benardos School of Mining and Metallurgical Engineering, National Technical University of Athens, Athens, Greece Chrysothemis Paraskevopoulou